American Identity

filipino-american-identity-crisis.jpg photo by Star Bulletin 

When you grow up in a society where mainstream society doesn’t represent or look like you, you will question your own identity. Such was my case.

Growing up I always wondered what and how it would be like to be White and not Filipino. While I didn’t hate how I looked, I did however prefer to be the “other” dominant race. Think about it? Any child would prefer it. Just imagine not being ask constantly what your “nationality” is. And when you say your “nationality” is American, then the next comment will be, “No, what I meant was where are you from?”

So to save yourself from further discussion, you tell them that your Filipino. Yes, when you are White in America, you are never asked what your nationality is or where you are from, even if you have a very thick Eastern European accent. It was just the way it was when I was growing up.

As a school aged and a teenager of color, I was always reminded of who and what I was. My parents reminded me that I shouldn’t try to act too American because I’m Filipino. American society also reminded me that I’m not really fully American because of the way I look.

To make matters worse, I also got the hypothetical question that went something like this, “If America goes to war against the Philippines, who would you fight for?” So, somehow because of the way I look, my loyalty was suspect. Of course my friends who were Irish, Polish, and Jewish were never asked the same question because since they are White, it was assumed that they are American and their loyalty and patriotism was never in questioned.

Ironically, I thought I wouldn’t go through the same experience when I lived in the Philippines for two years. While I certainly fit in because of my appearance, I immediately felt that culturally and emotionally, I wasn’t really Filipino. My students, friends, and relatives confirmed my notion when they stated that I act too much like an American.

What a dilemma, huh? So the identity crisis continued!

Fortunately, now that I’m older and more secured with who I am, I’m no longer at the state of confusion. I acknowledge and respect my Filipinoness and I will never deny myself of my parents’ culture. But in my years of searching, I have discovered that I’m an American first and foremost.

I think, act, and feel American. Yes, I was raised with Filipino culture and values but what I’ve discovered is that those same Filipino values have been mixed with American values. Consequently, as a benefit of my experience, my children do not have to feel confused about their own identity. They look Filipino and even speak the Filipino language but their thoughts, feelings, and culture is very American. Even my wife who is born and raised in the Philippines is very American.

This just goes to show that no matter how sometimes some Americans are not very accepting of differences and diversity, America itself as a whole is welcoming. America has a knack of taking everything in the world and making it her own, thus enabling herself to constantly evolve for the better. And, as long as America serves as the land of opportunity and freedom, new immigrants and their children will also experience the same identity crisis. But no matter how you slice it, these same people will be woven into the American fabric who help create a safety blanket for new people in search of new and better life.

  1. RJ Said,

    Nice post Chris:)

    Whle I’ve been acculturated with the norms, beliefs and behavioral expectations of this Western society, I’m happy to say that I haven’t been assimilated…yet ^_^

    I was 17 and just finished high school when we immigrated from the Philippines so I did not share your identity crisis because I believed I was a Filippino first and foremost. It was definitely a shock to the system though (arriving in the middle of winter no less!) A stranger in a strange land? You betcha! But this strange land has been good to me and afforded me opportunities that wouldn’t have been possible had I stayed back in the far east so for this I am grateful :)
    RJs last blog post..Take a Day Off, Do Nothing At All.

  1. RC Said,

    Thank you for that perspective. My great-grandmother arrived in the US from Germany, when she was in her 20s. I remember her stories of how people would look down on her, because she was German, not American. She would encounter the same questions you have, even though, yes, she looked “American” (whatever that look is, since that look changes from person to person).

    You’ve given me some idea of how she must have felt - trying to find her identity in this strange land - one that afforded many opportunities for her, as well.

    I’ve also heard stories from my grandmother of how the other kids in school would look down on her (she was born and bred here), due to her heritage, as her mom had carried traditions from the “old country” to the US, and these shaped my grandmother’s upbringing.

    I do have cousins who are part Hispanic and others with an Asian background, who still encounter this as well.

    RCs last blog post..Just like my mother

  1. Tara R. Said,

    I’ve never had to deal with this, being a white kid from the suburbs. My daughter had an interesting experience when she was in China two years ago. She was treated like some sort of celebrity ~ locals wanted to take her picture and have their photo taken with her. (She is tall, blonde, and American). She was a little unnerved by all the attention. But, she also said being treated differently (sometimes the attention wasn’t positive) was very strange and gave her a better prespective on being judged solely on her ethnicity.

  1. vered Said,

    I can relate. I was born and raised in Israel and have a slight foreign accent. All is fine until I start talking, but when I do, some people are taken aback because they realize I’m a foreigner.

    Having said that, my experiences here have generally been positive and I do agree with you that the U.S. in general is very welcoming - I think much more so than Europe, for example.

    vereds last blog post..Best Shot Monday: Random Thoughts On Paper Mache, Connectivity and Television

  1. It’s definitely interesting to think about because I am a white male American. I never really had any of those feelings growing up and I’ve never been outside the US so I can’t relate on the same level. It’s nice to know that you at least feel that Americans on a whole are very welcoming. One thing that I’ve recently been trying to do is when I’m describing a person I no-longer say the color of their skin. I try to just say that man or woman, not that Asian man or black woman. Who cares what they look like on the outside. It’s certainly worth trying if you find yourself describing people to others.

    Focus On Your Money Makers last blog post..Profile of a Money Maker: Shanel Yang

  1. Marelisa Said,

    Hi Chris: I lived outside of Panama most of my life–in several different countries–until the past few years. I was born in Panama, as were my parents and grandparents, but I feel like I don’t quite fit in here. It’s a small country and a lot of people here are very narrow minded. Sometimes it bothers me, but most of the time I’m just grateful that I’ve had the opportunity to experience so much and have so many different experiences.

    Marelisas last blog post..How Gratitude Can Change Your Life

  1. I can relate to this so well growing up as an American Born Chinese. From my experience, most places I have lived (all large cities) Americans are not very accepting of all cultures. Not until our recent move have I felt comfortable sharing my culture and traditions without being judged. My daughter is mixed with so much between myself and her father, that one of my biggest concerns was where she would grow up. I wanted so much for her to grow up in a culturally diverse place, where she would not stick out like an eye sore, much like I did.

    Sandy (Momisodes)s last blog post..Droppin’ Like Flies

  1. @RJ– Your experience is much like some of my friends who moved here when they were adults or close to being adults. Yes, the identity crisis is different since you were already sure of yourself before being exposed to American culture. Sometimes I did wish that I grew more in the Philippines rather than in America. But that’s only a wish. In reality, I’m still very fortunate to have been raised in the United States. I like who I am now and this due to my up bringing here.

    @RC–It’s only through personal stories that we can really know how people struggled to fit in in our society. This is one of the reasons why I always reserve judgement of people because we are so diverse that no one can really know what we all feel.

    @Tara R–I’m glad that your daughter had the experience of being immersed in a different culture. I’m sure her life is enriched by the experience.

    @Vered–Ahhhh, the accent…I really don’t know why people make such a big deal about it.

    @Focus On Your Money Maker–I also started describing people with out mentioning their race a few years back. I only mention someones race when people ask what the person look like…It takes getting used to…

    @Marelisa–Sounds like a move is in place…My wife was the same way. She always said that her personality was not meant for the Philippines. And she was right.

    @Sandy–Interestingly, my Chinese and Korean friends also went to through the same thing…Well, since you are in Cambridge, you don’t have to worry about Babisode sticking out. She’ll blend it perfectly.

  1. ilinap Said,

    You know I can relate to this post! I love the cartoon. Culture, heritage, ethnicity, citizenship, and race are so complicated these days. One thing does not define us; we are not such simplistic beings.

  1. Jade Said,

    Interesting topic. Something my husband and I can relate too. My husband is dutch but he is not white as dutch people are. His parents also comes from a very mixed heritage. His mom is Indonesian- has a Jewish/Dutch father and a Indonesia mother. My husband’s father is Dutch/India.

    I was born and raised in the Philippines but I do think like a European now.I am more open minded- in a way I think that it is good for me. I am not saying though that Filipino thinking is bad;) Just too many superstitions and so….

    Jades last blog post..Bzzzzzzzzzz Busy Busy Me plus & 7 Continent Tag

  1. Sara Said,

    It’s so hard that kids really start noticing these differences in the adolescent years. Tweens and teens have it tough enough trying to figure out who they are without trying to decipher who everyone else thinks they’re supposed to be as well.

    In the kids I work with, some really want to embrace their unique heritage, while others stay far, far away from the subject. It seems like an ebb and flow kind of thing as they discover where they feel authentic and explore the places in between.

    Saras last blog post..Writing Down the Rabbit Hole: Eight Ways to Keep Your Blogging Habit Simple

  1. This was a beautiful post, Chris. Australia is also incredibly multicultural and being such a new country, many older Australians still find it hard to get used to the many different faces and religions of people they view as immigrants. The funny thing is unless you’re Aboriginal everybody in Australia is descended from immigrants.

    A good friend of my husband’s and his ex business partner was born in Hong Kong and though he sounds EXACTLY the same as any other fair dinkum Aussie, people would always say to Musicman “Who’s your Chinese friend”. We would all joke about it, but I know he must get sick of it.

    I was born an Australian, but I spent my first 10 years in New Zealand. And even though these countries are neighbours and very similar, I was teased a lot for my Kiwi accent when I returned home. I hated being picked on, but moving to North Queensland where many of the families were generational townsfolk who had never gone more than 200km in either direction, I stuck out like a sore thumb. A funny talking misfit from a weird nomadic hippie family. So, I have a little idea how it feels to not fit in. I’ve felt that my whole life in fact. I’m much more passionate, intense and cultured than the average Aussie, who is generally cruisy to the point of apathy and sport obsessed.

    I think I have only started to feel more Australian since I had my son because now I can really see that I am so lucky to raise my child here. Australia is a free and democratic country with little poverty, amazing climate and geography, and a high standard of living. My son is one of the world’s privileged children and no matter where he wanders in his life, he can return here and for that I am grateful.

    To be honest, Chris, I think every country has its faults and its biases. It’s nice to have a national identity, but it’s not as important as your individual one. We get to define who we are, not others, and that’s something we all need to remember when we feel like the outsider. You are who you choose to be.

    Kelly

  1. Hi Chris,

    This story reminds me of the one my grandmother told when she arrived from Finland. It was 1912, she was 19 and felt out of place in America. For a long time she wanted to go back home. She slowly adjusted, became part of the American culture, but was always a Finn at heart.

    I don’t think it matters which country you come from, or what color you are, it’s a matter of finding your place in our culture, and learning how to be proud of your heritage. If people judge you for your skin color, accent, or nationality, it’s their problem, not yours.

  1. Grandy Said,

    Am I being naive to say that I hope things are better now? Where I grew up, there was a lot of diversity. But I know many areas were not. I just hope that kids can be raised not feeling different…but maybe I’m just being Pollyana like.

    Grandys last blog post..I’m back…but barely

  1. Bruno Said,

    Excellent post Chris - At first I did not know how your posting was going to end - Being a Canadian, ethnicity is a non-issue - Canada is very diverse with a high ratio of immigrants to natives. But having worked and lived in the United States, I do understand being a visible minority as well as being patriotic to America - Great post!

  1. david Said,

    interesting post, Chris! My wife is Chinese (and I’m pinoy, ofcourse). My kids will really be confused. :)
    davids last blog post..The Meaning of Life

  1. Ruthie Said,

    Great post Chris! Even though I’m considered “white’, I do have a native-american background. Great-great grandmother was full blooded Cherokee. I used to get asked the same question “What nationality are you?” because of my dark olive complexion.

    Ruthies last blog post..Wanna Sell Text Links On Your Blog?

  1. MizFit Said,

    as always a thought provoking post (how do you do it so consistently?!)—and yet I bed to differ :)
    I actually was asked often growing up (and often during Desert Storm) whom I would pick if we went to war against Israel (inane but true)…and how if I didnt say america I should go live in Israel etc.

    I love the you are whom you choose to be sentiment.

    M.

  1. @ilinap–I actually know people who say these things instead of just saying that they are Filipino

    @Jade– I think because of the work situation and our ability to get acculturated easily, Filipinos are truly becomming global citizens.

    @Sara– You are right…It’s bad enough that kids have to go through normal adolescent stuff, it’s even harder when the question of racial or cultural identity comes into play.

    @Kelly–You are not alone…Many of us because of mobility and other factors have struggled with who we are. But the most important thing really is where we end-up in this journey of national or individual identity.

    @Barbara–I wish more people would think like you…You are so dead on!

    @Grandy–This is why I try to do my best to make sure that my children are secure about their own identity. I don’t want them to feel like the way I felt growing up.

    @Bruno–I gotta visit Canada one of these days.

    @David–My cousin is the same way. He is married to a Chinese woman…They won’t be confused if they know that they are both…:)

    @Ruthie–I use to cringe when I was ask the same question, but now I wear my Filipinoness proudly because it is who I am and I know that at the end of the day, I am an American.

    @Mizfit–Thanks! I just don’t understand why such questions need to be asked. I guess it’s the same thing as asking a child to pick the mom or the dad during a divorce proceeding…How sad…

  1. Re: Yes, when you are White in America, you are never asked what your nationality is or where you are from. And yet, my dad is white, but his nationality is always questioned due to his British accent. My dad left England at the age of 20 and moved to Canada. That means he spent 20 years in England and 55 years in Canada, but people constantly say to him “Ah, you are British” when they hear him talk for the first time. 55 years in Canada! My dad’s response is always “No, I am not. I am Canadian.”

    Fascinating how as a species we feel the need to pigeon hole.

  1. Max Said,

    I’m white and I’m always asked where I’m from even though most of my family has been year for hundreds of years.

Add A Comment